| Platinum | K-Macho's |
| Gold | Casa Amigos |
| Silver | Mi Ranchito |
| Bronze | El Saguaro Mexican Grill |
| Top Pick | Carmen's Cocina II |
| Top Pick | Carmens Cocina II |
| Top Pick | Chapala |
| Top Pick | Jose Pepper's |
| Top Pick | Kmacho's Mexican Restaurant and Cantina |
| Top Pick | Taco John's |